Enfield Local Plan: Inspector’s initial view

Steven Lee, the Inspector appointed to Examine the Enfield Local Plan, has now issued his first letter setting out his view about the ‘soundness’ of the Council’s proposals. The Local Plan is a large and complex document. It is over 500 pages long and included over 7,000 pages of supporting evidence. It contains dozens of policies all of which have been looked at by Mr Lee.

The Society was particularly concerned with policies affecting the Green Belt and tall buildings. The particular policies which we were concerned about were RUR.02 (Hadley Wood); RUR.03 (Land west of Rammey Marsh); RUR.04 (M25/J24); RUR.08 (Sloeman’s Farm); PL10 (Vicarage Farm/Chase Park); PL11 (Crews Hill) and SA1.2 (Tall buildings Enfield Town).

On Monday 15th June the Inspector’s Letter was published, coded as document IN14. You can find it on the Enfield Council’s Local Plan web page. The letter is 37 pages long (with 244 paragraphs) and goes into a lot of detail about what Mr Lee has seen and what he wishes to see by way of changes. What follows here are the Inspectors comments relating to the areas (listed above) of interest to the Society.

References in square brackets like this [1] refer to paragraphs in the Inspector’s letter IN14.

General comments

A number of Groups, including the Society, commented that the Local Plan is inconsistent, included duplication and included errors. The inspector has confirmed this in paragraph [8] and goes on to suggest changes to the languages in [9–11].

PL10 Chase Park

The Inspector has not rejected the proposal for development on Vicarage Farm.

A key component of the proposal was the creation of a “country park” at the north of the site and forming an extension to Trent Park. During the hearings Comer Homes objected to this proposals, insisting it should remain part of the current farm. However, Mr Lee has concluded that the creation of the Park is a important ‘compensation’ to development and the Council needs to ensure it is delivered at the same time as development. Para [53] says: Therefore, to be effective the policy should include a mechanism that ensures the country park extension is delivered in a timely manner alongside the delivery of any housing.

The Inspector has made a number of references to the Sites of Importance for Nature Conservation (SINC) which could be affected by development, see [58, 60, 63]. These comments appear to support the Society’s view that these sites need protection.

The Inspector has noted neighbouring Trent Park and the reference to ‘buffers’ to ‘respect’ it. The Inspectors recommends firmer definitions of these buffers—see [56, 61].

The Inspector has not concluded that development south of Enfield Road is unsound. But he does make recommendations about ‘protecting’ the neighbouring residential properties [62].

PL11 Crews Hill

The Inspector has not rejected the proposal for development at Crews Hill.

Two areas west of the railway line were proposed by the Council to be removed from Green Belt even though little or no development was proposed: the golf course and Kings Oak Plain. The inspector has rejected that [12, 13]. The Inspector has also raised concerns about the impact of development on the golf course to the SINC [14] and has suggested that no development takes place on the golf course [16].

The Inspector believes that there are no exceptional circumstances to remove the whole area around the Glasgow Stud SINC from the Green Belt, but does conclude that some development could take place [18, 19].

The area to the east of Theobalds Road (allocation SA11.6) was to have been removed from the Green Belt but without any apparent development proposed except a school. The Inspector has rejected this and SA11.6 should remain in the Green Belt [20, 21].

The Society was concerned about the impact on important views from The Ridgeway from tall buildings to the east of the railway line along Cattlegate Road ‘poking up’ above the railway embankment. The Inspector has made reference to this in para [28].

The Society was concerned about the impact of designated heritage buildings in the proposed areas (Owls Hall and The Paddocks). The Inspector has referenced these assets in [30, 40, 44].

RUR.02 (Hadley Wood)

The Inspector has rejected the inclusion of this site within the Local Plan [68–72].

RUR.03

This is not referenced in the Inspector’s letter.

RUR.04 (M25, J24)

The Inspector has rejected the inclusion of the site within the Local Plan [73–78]. However, at the start of the year the Council signaled its intention to sell this area for a data centre. We currently do not know what effect the Inspector’s conclusions will be.

RUR.07 (Whitewebbs)

The Council’s proposals for this area suggest that significant built form might be likely for this site. Given that, the Inspector has concluded that very special circumstances are needed for it to be removed from the Green Belt. The Inspector has included this in his letter [82]: If the Council were intent on limiting the nature of development to that which meets the Green Belt exceptions, then this might be acceptable. However, it is quite clear that this is not what the Plan is proposing, certainly with regard to RUR.06 and RUR.07. In these circumstances I am not persuaded that it is appropriate to allocate land in the Green Belt for what amounts to ‘inappropriate development’ without proper assessment of the degree of harm likely to the Green Belt or what the Council would be willing to accept.

He also includes this [87]: For the avoidance of doubt, these conclusions have no bearing on the permissions that have already been granted. I am not suggesting that the forms of development
proposed or permitted are not capable of meeting the national policy tests. Rather, I am concluding that the policies as drafted are not effective and are not capable of being made so through modification.

RUR.08 (Sloeman’s Farm)

The Inspector is less clear about the size of the built form on this site than with RUR.07. (RUR.08 is designated for a burial site.) The Inspector has suggested the allocation be removed from the Plan but that does not exclude a future application coming forward [84].

Tall buildings in Enfield Town

This is covered in [176]. The Inspector says “With regard to Enfield Town Centre, I am not persuaded that the evidence justifies the appropriate heights proposed, particularly for Palace Gardens.”

Para [177] says: To that end, Appendix D should be modified to reflect ‘Revision B’ in the CoGS for Enfield Town Centre. In addition, modifications are needed to Appendix D to ensure consistency with the modified policy. This includes removing any indication that the plan is automatically supportive of buildings taller than what is stipulated, including, but not limited to, Enfield Town Centre. This would be at odds with the policy. The “Revision B” referred-to relates to the Council’s own evidence submitted in relation to Enfield Town. The Council assessed three building heights: 24m, 27m and 39m. Revision B was 27m.

Other points

SA1.5 (St Anne’s School, Enfield Town)

The Inspector has requested this is deleted from the Plan [104].

H10 Traveller Accommodation

The Local Plan made reference to the need, but did not contain any site allocations. These were contained in the separate Traveller Local Plan which went through Regulation 19 consultation in October/November 2025. The Inspector makes reference to this in [141] and says that the separate Traveller Plan must be submitted before the end of 2026 for Inspection and before the Inspector’s final report on the Enfield Local Plan.

HMOs

The Inspector has drawn attention to the lack of any policy on Housing in Multiple Occupancy (HMO) [143–150] and has suggested that to be effective the Plan will require modification.

Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.